Showing posts with label fantasy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fantasy. Show all posts

Thursday, June 07, 2007

Science Fiction, Fantasy, and Horror, Part Two: Three Mini Reviews

Over at Skotos I'm continuing my work on Xenagia, our new science-fiction, fantasy, and horror community. Thus these three genres remain foremost in my mind, and I'm continuing my series here discussing them. If you missed it, you should read my first article on this topic, which covered history and ten top games in the genres.

(I've got one more article planned, for two weeks from now.)

The interesting thing about the fantasy, science-fiction, and horror genres is how completely they describe hobbyist game production in the United States from the early 1970s to the late 1990s. Aside from historical military conflicts, if a hobbyist game came out in the United States, the odds were at least 50/50 that it was a genre game. I still have about half a bookshelf full of Dragon Pass, The Riddle of the Ring, Dune, Kings & Things, Hacker, and other similar games from this period.

However there were always three games that really stood out to me as the definitive American hobbyist games, and which got much love and play over the years until I discovered Eurogames: Cosmic Encounter, Illuminati, and Wiz-war. I played all three for the first time in college and they largely defined my gameplaying for a decade. They've now all fallen out of favor, especially by crowds won over by Eurogames, but they're still worth a look, so here's my thoughts on them:

Cosmic Encounter (B)

Cosmic Encounter is, at heart, a simple wargame. Each turn you are randomly told what player to attack, you load up some attackers, you and the defender each get a chance to gather allies, and then you blind bid attack cards which are added to your force numbers. Simple.

The joy of the game comes in two elements: the social interaction and the powers.

The social interaction, embodied by that option to gather allies, is well done because there's always a reason to join in a fight. As an attacker you get a presence on the planet--which ultimately means victory points--while as a defender you get valuable new cards added to your hand. Few games manage to give players real reasons to get involved in other conflicts, and thus stay involved in the game, but Cosmic Encounter does it effortlessly.

The powers are what give the game color and appeal. Each player has an individual and unique ability which gives him an advantage over his peers. One power makes a player's troops four times as powerful, another lets the player choose his bidding card after he sees his opponent's, and another can choose whether "high" or "low" bin wins. The game also gains additional color through "flares" and "edicts", which you can draw amidst the blind-bidding number cards.

Cosmic Encounter is by no means a perfect game. As with many wargames it can drag on if there's too much back and forth between the players. I love the game when it lasts 30 minutes to an hour, but at 3 or 4 hours I'm ready to claw my eyes out. Thus, it's a bit of crapshoot sometimes.

Cosmic Encounter was released in four different versions over the years. Eon Publishing put out the original game and supplemented it with many expansions which added to the color and thus interest of the game. It's the best respected version of the game, but also the most expensive on secondary markets. West End Games and Hasbro each put out an unsupplemented version of the game, neither of which old-time players care for that much. The advantages of the Hasbro version are that it has great pieces--the only edition where that's true--and that it's in print. The best compromise may be the Mayfair version, where you can get a pretty expansive version of the game by buying Mayfair's original Cosmic Encounters and the expansion More Cosmic Encounters (though they're a little pricey on the secondary market too).

However in the modern world I think Cosmic Encounter Online may be an even better choice. It's by the original Eon folks, it's got a set of alien powers that has gradually increased, and it plays fast, thus never running into the main flaw of the game.

Overall I give Cosmic Encounter a B. It's got solid mechanics, with some fear of long-play, and it's got colorful theming.

Illuminati (C+)

Illuminati is just barely a genre game since it's mostly about silly conspiracies. However, it is one of my triad of classic American games, and it does include Servants of Cthulhu, UFOs, and other fanastic elements, so I've included it here.

The basic idea behind Illuminati is that you're trying to take over the world. You do this through webs of power. Each web of power begins with your Illuminati, which is who you're playing. You might get some special powers and/or special victory conditions from that group. You then use your Illuminati to take over other groups. Each group has a name, a power, an income, and "control arrows", which help define how many groups it can take over.

The gameplay is pretty basic: you collect income, and either steal other players' groups, take over neutral groups, or destroy groups. You can spend money to help these activities, and you can encourage other players to do the same, sort of like the alliances in Cosmic Encounter (but without the rewards). However the true enjoyment in the game comes through its pure silliness, which is generally the case in Steve Jackson Games. Basically, Illuminati is the game where you can say "My Cattle Mutilators try and take over Animal Testing Labs".

Of my classic American games, Illuminati is the one I'm the least forgiving of, because it can drag on and on much more than any others for pretty much the same reasons: back-and-forth, a general flaw in a lot of American game designs. Nonetheless, it's a classic.

Illuminati has been released in a number of forms, all by Steve Jackson Games, including some mini-game editions and a Deluxe edition released back in 1987. The best version to get is probably the Deluxe edition that was released in 1999, as that one's the only one in full-color (with older editions having plain black and white cards). There was a CCG using some of the same ideas called Illumanti: New World Order, but it doesn't have quite the same gameplay. (In fact, it's fatally flawed in some ways, as I've had games where I never got a second turn because someone had already won).

Wiz-War (A)

Tom Jolly's game of warring wizards is one of my all-time favorites because it encapsulates so many of the good things in American game design. You have very freeform play, a huge variety of cards that introduce lots of fun chaos into the game, and really nice theming.

The basic idea is that you're a wizard, with a maze-like home base which is a 5x5 grid that contains your two treasures. Every other wizard has a similar base, and they're all connected together in a big tesserect-like shape. Your object is to get two other treasures back to the center of your home tile.

Each turn you move three spaces and play one or more cards. You have lots of number cards, which can be used to move faster or to power some spells, and you have spells, items, and other objects too, all randomly drawn as cards. As players wander back and forth trying to get treasures much interaction, combat, and fun occurs.

There are all the usual problems, from players getting eliminated to widely variable game length, but this one has enough variability and color to keep me interested anyway--unless I'm that unfortunate early eliminee.

There are seven editions of Wiz-War. I've never seen the earlier one, but all the recent ones have been published by Chessex. Sixth edition and "Classic" edition both used bigger board and generally nicer components, and thus are the ones to get. Sixth and Classic are actually entirely interchangeable and can actually be mixed together with a sixth edition expansion to allow for play by up to ten players. Chessex has been promising an eighth edition for something like a decade. The latest claim is that it'll be out this July, which I'll believe when I see. Since it's full color it would be well-worth waiting for the new game ... if you actually believed that Chessex was ever going to put it out.

Thursday, May 24, 2007

Science Fiction, Fantasy, and Horror, Part One: A History and Ten Top Games

In my real life I work for Skotos Tech, an online gaming company that's increasingly becoming an online entertainment company. Our newest site, which I launched last week, is Xenagia, a community site all about fantasy, science fiction, and horror. Thus far we've got a forum and a book index, with plans to add reviews in a couple of weeks.

(And, if you're interested in the topics, please stop on by, as we're working hard to create a community, particularly on the forums.)

Because of my work on Xenagia, I've been largely immersed in these three genres over the last couple of weeks, and that's what led to this article, talking about science-fiction and fantasy (and to a lesser extent, horror) in gaming.

A Brief History

Fantasy and science-fiction have, of course, been around for quite some time. Frankenstein (1818) is often referenced as one of the earliest entrants to the genre, but it took until the 20th century for more regular publication to occur. H.P. Lovecraft was writing great pulp science-fiction/horror stories in the 1920s and 1930s, then Robert E. Howard's Conan appeared in 1932 and Fritz Leiber's Fafhrd and Gray Mouser appeared in 1940.

However it wasn't until the 1960s that genre fiction burst into the mass market, and that was thanks to J.R.R. Tolkien. His famous Lord of the Rings first appeared in Britain in 1954 and 1955 and received some slight attention. Then in the 1960s it appeared in the United States, first in an illegal edition from Ace Books, then in an authorized Ballantine Books edition.

It was that later Ballantine edition that was discovered en masse by the Baby Boomers. Suddenly "Frodo Lives!" pins popped up at anti-war demonstrations and at love-ins. Tolkien's books became a touchstone for the generation, and they were just a part of a burgeoning flock of science-fiction and fantasy publications that achieved wider success than their niche predecessors. Robert Heinlein's Stranger in a Strange Land (1961) and the Lancer/Ace Conan books (1966-1977) were others that thus escaped into the mainstream.

The gaming field reacted to this in the 1970s when young designers brought up on these post-war science fiction and fantasy stories started creating games in their image. To that date all hobbyist game design in the United States had been centered on wargames. Now, however, a new game appeared that was more focused on individual characters and continuing games. That was Gary Gygax and Dave Arneson's Dungeons & Dragons (1973).

Gygax and Arneson weren't the only wargame publishers that had been moving toward fantasy and science-fiction publication. Newcomers like Metagaming Concepts and GDW, all influenced by the new cultural landscape of the 1960s, were edging into this area as well. Even older stalwart SPI was trying out genre games. However it was the success of D&D that would turn the whole hobbyist gaming industry on its ear, leading everyone to start publishing genre games in increasing numbers.

And that is what ultimately leads us today's gaming landscape, and its peculiar relationship to fantasy and science-fiction.

The Genres Today

In today's hobbyist gaming market there are broadly two types of games.

The Anglo-American designs ultimately derive from those wargaming and roleplaying origins. Today most Anglo-American board game publishers--including names such as Steve Jackson Games, Atlas Games, Fantasy Flight Games, and Wizards of the Coast (through Hasbro's Avalon Hill imprint)--were originally RPG publishers. The designers' ideas about game design are thus usually based on decades of American hobbyist publications. Because of those origins, they also tend toward the science-fiction and fantasy themes. As I've written elsewhere Anglo-America games are usually theme-heavy and mechanics-light. The games often lean toward the simulationistic, giving up simplicity for realism.

The German designs, meanwhile, derive ultimately (I think) from the SdJ, Germany's game of the year award. Thanks to powerful economic incentives the SdJ has encouraged a very specific type of game design which is generally lighter and more casual--and which typically has better designed and more carefully considered mechanics but less theming. And, the German games have typically avoided science-fiction and fantasy themes, partially because of their orientation toward the mass (German) market and partially because they don't have the historical origins in those genres than the Anglo-American hobbyist market does.

And from those two core types of games spawn a third: the hybrids. These are games published in countries other than the United States, Britain, or Germany. Without the institutional rules set by historical precedent, they're more able to pick and choose among the two major design schools. Thus games coming out of France and Italy in particular have been more free to use fantasy and science-fiction themes, but with abstract and polished Germanic mechanics. Increasingly American companies are also moving in this direction, with games from Atlas and Fantasy Flight in particular showing German design influence matched with more American themes.

And with that overview out of the way, let me briefly mention my top ten fantasy, science-fiction, and horror games, with some attention paid to where they came from.

Fantasy Games

I expected to have troubles coming up with top-rate fantasy games, but as it turns out there are a number that I was able to name without regrets. Fantasy Flight's superb wargame A Game of Thrones probably belongs here too, but I've instead given the space over to the more fantastical offerings. Fairy Tale and Dragon's Gold are two games that just barely missed my cut off for this list.

Descent. Anglo-American design, Fantasy Flight Games. A member of the "adventure game" genre, which has traditionally presented board games that are very similar to roleplaying games, thanks to the play of individual characters. Descent is quite simply the best of class. Each game you push your characters through a dungeon while the gamemaster throws monsters at you. If you can accomplish the goals, you win. It's a bit on the long-side, but has superb mechanics and ever better theming.

Dungeon Twister. Hybrid French design, Asmodee Editions. My favorite game from its year of publication, and one I'd play a lot more if I had more 2-player game opportunities. An excellent tactical game that's based on the careful allocation of resources as you try and kill your opponents' characters and get your own through the dungeon. On the other hand also wonderfully themed, thanks to the colorful characters and great art that you can expect from Asmodee. Really shows off the benefits of hybridized game design. [ Reviews ]

Grand Tribunal. Hybrid Anglo-American design, Atlas Games. I include this game primarily because you probably haven't heard of it, and it's worth some attention. Based on Atlas' superb Ars Magica RPG, Grand Tribunal is a Princes of Florence-like resource-management game where you're constantly trying to create the best magic items. It's got some American take-that play, but also some solid core mechanics. [ Review ]

Lord of the Rings. German design, Fantasy Flight. The smartest move Sophisticated Games made after getting the Lord of the Rings license was signing up Reiner Knizia to design some of their games. I'm talking here primarily about Knizia's superb cooperative board game which is probably the best game of its sort on the market, and which is always tight, tough, and heartbreaking. Every one of its three supplements is good too. [ Reviews ]

Wiz-War. Anglo-American design, Chessex. This is an entirely old school design which is fun because it's chaotic and surprising, not because the mechanics are particularly good. You're a wizard in a dungeon. You have two treasures. So does every other player/wizard. If you can get two other treasures to your home base, you win. The game can last for hours or minutes, which is another deficit, but there's still nothing like playing a double-double-strength sudden death on an opponent without defenses. Long, long out of print but Chessex swears they're going to have their full-color new edition out any day now; they've been saying that for about a decade, however. (Perhaps stupidly, I'm pretty sure they're really close this time.)

Science-Fiction Games

Though high-quality fantasy games are well-represented, I can't say the same of science-fiction. The following games are all good, but none of them reach the heights of Descent, Dungeon Twister, and Lord of the Rings, which are all superb exemplars of the fantasy genre. I know some people would include Starship Catan and Spacefarers of Catan in this listing, but they've generally struck me as too long and some of the weaker members of the Catan franchise, and don't rate as high for me as anything included below.

Blue Moon & Blue Moon City. German design, Fantasy Flight Games. Are they really science fiction? Probably not, but given the good science-fiction games are pretty slim pickings, I've included them here. At the least they're science fantasy, that amorphous blend of genre that lies somewhere between the one and the other. Though distinct games, Blue Moon and Blue Moon City share a setting, and Reiner Knizia did a great job on both designs, really highlighting the alien races and making them unique and interesting. Blue Moon is a good 2-player CCG-like game, while Blue Moon City is a great resource-management game. [ Reviews ]

Diceland. Anglo-American design, Cheapass Games. Here's another one that I'm betting not many people have seen. This is a game played with huge 12-sided cardboard dice that you toss around the table in an effort to destroy your opponents' pieces. It's largely dexterity based and has some very clever mechanisms. [ Reviews ]

Light Speed. Anglo-American design, Cheapass Games. There's almost nothing to this 5-10 minute game of rapid card placement. You try and play your cards in such a way as to blow up enemy ships and keep yourself protected. However, it's fast and original, and it has spaceships on the cards. [ Review ]

Mission: Red Planet.
Hybrid French design, Asmodee Editions. Another good design from Asmodee, clearly showing that they're willing to put out lots of genre games, where German companies haven't been. This is majority-control with a few twists and goes into my "one-hour El Grande" category. Terrific design, and fun steampunk theming. [ Review ]

Horror Games

Just as there was a step-down from fantasy to science-fiction in number and quality of games, I think the same is true from science-fiction to horror. I almost left this category blank entirely. I know some people would include Betrayal at House on the Hill (which I find entirely random and poorly produced) and Fury of Dracula (which I've never played due to length). Beyond that, there isn't a lot exciting in horror, though I've played some cute themed card games, and any number of amusing (but not well-designed) Lovecraftian games.

Arkham Horror. Anglo-American design, Fantasy Flight Games. And my sole entrant in horror is actually Lovecraftian too, specifically Fantasy Flight's second edition of Richard Launius' Call of Cthulhu board game. Kevin Wilson did a great job in this new edition of making the game more evocative and colorful and generally improved the design as well. Though the game is loooong my RPG group has always enjoyed playing it. [ Reviews, including some other Cthulhu games ]

Conclusion

If you disagree or think I missed the best f/sf/h game ever, the comment link should be right below ...

Wednesday, November 01, 2006

The Quality of Fantasies

I’m happy to have another great article by Mikko Karvonen for you today. Clap if you believe in Orcs and Dwarves.

I love fantasy as a genre. I enjoy it in books, comics, movies and tv-series and, of course, in games. I have to admit that fantasy-theming alone is often enough to get me to take a closer look at any given boardgame. However, partly because I am so strongly attached to the genre, I also tend to be rather critical towards it. A bland generic fantasy with your average orcs and elves does very little to impress me, while an original take on the subject can be enjoyable in itself. So I thought I'd take a look at some of the latest fantasy boardgames, the way the genre is implemented into them and how it affects the playing experience.

To narrow my scope, I'll focus on selected games of different types published after the year 2000 with fantasy worlds developed solely with non-computerised gaming in mind. This excludes games like Warhammer Fantasy Battle, HeroQuest, World of Warcraft: the Boardgame, Game of Thrones and War of the Ring. Some of them I like, some of the I don't, but I want to make sure I'll actually be able to finish this piece at some point. So, on to the games. Please note that I focus only on the fantasy elements of the games, not the quality of the game otherwise.

I'll start with Wizard Kings, even though it's a bit older game than my other examples, as it offers the most generic and bland implementation of fantasy I could find. This is mostly due to the way the game is put together: no background information, no personalities, no special powers. Nothing to add the meat to the bones. Just a bunch of units with fantasy-themed names and pictures. There are some interesting elements in various different armies, like the boarmen, but they are not utilised at all. Even the maps consist of your average environments, with only the stone circles to add a touch of otherness to them. Rating (1-10): 2

Battleground: Fantasy Warfare does not fare much better. The developers have, perhaps wisely, declared that they have intentionally avoided publishing any information about their game world to give themselves room to develop it more, but they have also given the players a little motivation beyond traditional fantasy clichés to create their own scenarios and vendettas. This hasn't exactly been helped by the selection of the first armies: humans, orcs, undeads and, as the first expansion pack, elves. The last have a bit of unique twist to them thanks to elk-riding cavalries and animal-commanding wolfkin and bearkin, but other races have just copied the regular strengths and weaknesses of their equivalents from other miniature games. Rating: 3

Another example of badly developed fantasy world can be found in HeroScape. It does have a vague background story about angelic beings recruiting warriors from various times and spaces to fight for them, but frankly, it's just an excuse to include all sorts of fantasy and science fiction characters in one game. Luckily, the developers have had the courage to go all the way and really come up with lots of different flavored units and even get a bit of personal touch into the miniatures here and there. This helps to save HeroScape's face a bit, but still I would have loved a bit stronger environment to encourage certain kind of combinations instead of throwing practically anything into the battlefield together. Rating: 4

Magic: the Gathering is a bit trickier customer in this analysis. In first glance, it does seem to have the same problem as HeroScape: you can throw almost anything together if you wish. However, MtG has a couple things to support its cause. First, various theme-decks are actually a fun, and sometimes even viable, way to play the game. Second, the colour-scheme makes sure that usually most cards in any given deck are at least thematically linked. Third, there is actually some interesting story-information in the art and the flavour text of the cards. Fourth, the developers have not been shy about making unusual twists to old fantasy favorites or creating new ideas of their own. Some cards have actually made me say 'Wow' when I've seen their art or flavour details. Rating: 7

So far I've been quite critical about old, familiar fantasy clichés, but sometimes they actually work. All you have to do is give them a touch of personality, a game where they fit the basic idea really well, and be really honest and sincere about it. A good example of this is Runebound (and Descent, which takes place in the same world). It's got all the traditional elements you can think of: big heroes, treasures, magical items, nasty monsters, evil necromancers and powerful dragons. But since the idea is to create the ultimate, quintessential fantasy adventure, it's all good and workable. There is enough originality and details to make them work. The magical sword is not just a magical sword, but the mighty Sword of Light! The enemies are not just average zombies but a temple of evil necromancers! And the heroes are not quite your usual fantasy types (despite the Red Scorpion and Her Amazing Levitating Boobs! -act), but wizards are a bit crazy and warriors either not-so-pretty non-humans or suspicious looking über-males. Various expansions help the cause as well by adding different spices to the usual fantasy mix: Island of Dread a touch of Cthulhian monsters, Midnight (based on FFG's own RPG) a world where the ultimate evil has won the great war and the upcoming Sands of Al-Kalim a shade of Arabian nights. Rating: 7

Yet the most impressive fantasy worlds are filled with unique or unusually well-developed ideas. One of my personal favorites is found in the miniature game Warmachine and further developed in it's RPG-version, Iron Kingdoms. It mixes an original take on many fantasy races with a world going through it's industrial revolution that is fueled not only by coal and iron but also magic, allowing the creation of huge machines of war, steampowered robots called steamjacks. It's an impressive vision filled with lots of background detail, rich and well-thought versions of old favorites like elves, religion and undead, and heaps of very, very cool opportunities for gaming. The only small problem with Warmachine (if you don't mind the ridiculously large shoulder pads many characters choose to wear) is that it actually fails to utilise the potential of the world as so much extra has been developed for the purposes of Iron Kingdoms RPG. But I know several people who own the core rules and some miniatures of Warmachine just because steamjacks and other unique aspects of the world are so awesome, so it's clearly doing many, many things right. Rating: 9

Perhaps a bit ironically, the most original and charming fantasy world in the current boardgaming scene comes from the man often blamed for dry and thinly themed games: Reiner Knizia. I am, of course, talking about Blue Moon (and BM City). It's main attraction are it's different races and characters. In Blue Moon, we don't get elves, orcs, centaurs or even minotaurs, but a set of definitely unique, yet still familiar enough to be understood, people. Knowledge-preserving technomages, reckless birdmen, passionate traders, spiritual guardians of different elements and gangs of childlike people that get everywhere. I've never been able to decide which of them I like more. Okay, it has its race of (half)-naked amazons which, admittedly, is a bit cheesy. But even that works, since the women in the cards are portrayed so strong, spiritual and capable that they are much less objects and more emancipated than you'd expect. Which brings us to a very important point, sadly overlooked by some of the other games on this list: the world of Blue Moon is enhanced by stunning art. Impressive visuals go a long way in crafting a truly unique world with a clear sense of wonder, fantasy and otherness. Rating: 9,5

Finally, let's take a little peek at the future and the game that may be the Next Big Thing: BattleLore. Of course, we don't know everything about it yet, so I won't make a final assessment. Based on the current information, it seems to be taking a very traditional approach on fantasy. We get the holy quartet: Warriors, Rogues, Wizards and Clerics. We get very, very traditional races and monsters from dwarves to hill giants. And we get them all mixed up with historical events. Frankly, I'm not very impressed by this. Medieval Europe had a wide range of folk stories, mythologies and legends that would have offered an excellent, yet rarely used background for supernatural and fantasy elements that would fit the history well. Instead they seem to use the bland, D&D-ized version of fantasy with a bit of local colour. It may work, but at this point, I'm quite skeptical.

So, it is obvious that the same theme can be implemented into a boardgame for better or worse. When I look at this list of games, all of which I happen to like, I know I'm far more likely to play the ones that do this thing well. It's an extra layer of dedication put into the development of the game and thus adds it's own bonus to my gaming experience as well. I don't mind playing an abstract game, or one with a thin theme and good mechanics, but when I'm looking for a strongly genre-influenced game, I prefer one that does its theme well.

It's also worth considering: would spending a bit more time on adding extra bits of theme to more German-styled games be worth it's while. After all, there are several good examples of this paying off very well. Havoc: the Hundred Years War is basically a variation of poker, but it has gotten a lot of praise for its medieval art and historical tidbits. Funny Friends owes a lot to its non-politically correct approach, part of Reef Encounter's charm is just its strangely captivating theme and I'm fairly certain that Ticket to Ride wouldn't have been the hit it is on a generic map and cities A, B, C...